Comment on features or suggest new features for inclusion in the game.
Claudebot
Argent II Offline
Premium
PremiumPremium Visit My Farm Visit My Farm Joined: Mon Sep 01, 2014 4:41 pm Posts: 630

Driving Competition Corrections

Post by Argent II »

I've been watch driving competition videos, and I I'm seeing the same error in stat requirements for Marathon and Obstacle driving as I pointed out earlier in Driven Dressage, namely that Strength is overvalued. I'd even argue that it isn't a necessity in any of these three sports as the carriages used are light and maneuverable and other attributes outweigh the need for strength. You can see video of each type of competition here: http://www.americandrivingsociety.org/combined.asp

I believe Agility > Intelligence > Stamina > Speed/Strength would be more appropriate for Marathon, and Balance > Agility > Speed > Strength/Intelligence would be more appropriate for Obstacles.
Image


(14:43:36) Nate: argie goes around the farm at foaling time with a tape measurer, an angle measurer, and a club
Claudebot
Argent II Offline
Premium
PremiumPremium Visit My Farm Visit My Farm Joined: Mon Sep 01, 2014 4:41 pm Posts: 630

Re: Driving Competition Corrections

Post by Argent II »

If you look at this image of ideal body types for different sports, the build represented as perfect for Marathon and Obstacles are much heavier than any competitive horse in either of these disciplines could reasonably be. Most Combined Driving horses are warmbloods, not drafts.
Image
Image


(14:43:36) Nate: argie goes around the farm at foaling time with a tape measurer, an angle measurer, and a club
Claudebot
Syn Offline Visit My Farm Visit My Farm Joined: Tue Aug 04, 2015 3:32 am Posts: 158

Re: Driving Competition Corrections

Post by Syn »

Argent II wrote:x



Where is that image from? I'd like to see it in full.
APEX STUD
«α» suffix
dutch harness horses
MCh.++ Charcoal «α»
MCh.++ RH Thoughtful «α»
Claudebot
Fox13 Offline Visit My Farm Visit My Farm Joined: Mon Sep 07, 2015 3:38 am Posts: 110

Re: Driving Competition Corrections

Post by Fox13 »

Help menu, help guides, Seina's Extensive User Guide.

Scroll down to the 'Entering Competitions' section.

It's in blue right below larissar's quote (p1, p2)
Claudebot
Argent II Offline
Premium
PremiumPremium Visit My Farm Visit My Farm Joined: Mon Sep 01, 2014 4:41 pm Posts: 630

Re: Driving Competition Corrections

Post by Argent II »

merp
Image


(14:43:36) Nate: argie goes around the farm at foaling time with a tape measurer, an angle measurer, and a club
Claudebot
Scythian Offline Visit My Farm Visit My Farm Joined: Thu Nov 05, 2015 4:35 pm Posts: 426

Re: Driving Competition Corrections

Post by Scythian »

I agree with Argent II's finding, even though my Heavy Pony type SideKick has benefited (perhaps unduly) from this.

See my post "What Is Strength?" for a related issue.
Claudebot
Alana Offline Visit My Farm Visit My Farm Joined: Wed Sep 30, 2015 8:31 am Posts: 100

Re: Driving Competition Corrections

Post by Alana »

This definitly needs to be looked over, in Log pull I see strength as a vital thing, but marathon/obstacle and dressage driving has less to do with strength and much more to do with speed, agility, balance and so forth

Return to “Comments and Suggestions”